Network of Thought Reading Group
Time and Place:
"If, in short, there is a community of computers living in my head, there had also better be somebody who is in charge; and, by God, it had better be me." -J. Fodor
Contact Victor:
networkofthought@victorgom.es
Twitter
Substack
Contact Bodhi:
bodhiswatabiswas@gmail.com
Twitter First and Third Wednesday each month 11:00 EST (16:00 GMT/20:30 IST) @ zoom
For Zoom PW or Discord invite: Email Victor or Bodhi!
Some have responded to the replication crisis by arguing that there is instead a theory crisis in psychology. Because of this, there is a focus on particular effects and phenomena rather than developing frameworks which generalize and extend beyond the particular experiments they are tested within. The goal of this reading group is to focus on theoretical frameworks within cognitive science, though of course experiments will often be a part of the discussion as a focus on theory does not require a total disregard for experimentation. The focus, at least in the start, will largely be issues surrounding language, as the coordiantors are versed in psycholinguistics. But, we hope that as time goes on, other members can suggest and help lead sessions on theoretical topics that may not have anything to do with language at all (though we are sure whether anything cognitive is fully seperable from anything else will be a consistent part of discussion). Our first meetings will focus on the Language of Thought hypothesis, most (in)famously associated with Jerry Fodor, as it has been experiencing a bit of a revival, and it touches on many other interesting issues surrounding cognitive architecture, modularity, and learning. The sessions will be discussion-oriented, with the hope being that we develop a shared understanding of the relevance of these theoretical frameworks to conducting experiments today. All who are curious are welcome, and any who are confused are encouraged to reach out to ask questions on the discord. There is a firm "there is no such thing as a stupid question" policy,Although please don't feel discouraged if one of us (...Victor) asks for clarification! He's weird about that for some reason, just consider it a love language or whatever. so do not hesitate to ask!
The only expectation is that you do the readings. You're still welcome to participate if you haven't done the readings as long as you are mindful.
Schedule
Remember, if you ever find yourself struggling with any of the readings or concepts, reach out! Either directly to the coordinators or to the entire group over discord.
- Meeting 1 (July 3rd): The Best Players, The Best Game
- Language of Thought
- π The best game in town: The reemergence of the language-of-thought hypothesis across the cognitive sciences? by Quilty-Dunn et al.
- Be sure to read the replies to the piece (Open Peer Commentary, starting at p.22), as well as the reply to the replies (Author's Response, p.27)
- Meeting 2 (July 17th): The Best Players, Best Games
- Brains & Bodies
- Meeting 3 (Aug. 7th): The Best Players, The Best Game
- Let the bodies hit the floor
- π Disembodying Cognition by Anjan Chatterjee
- π Theoretical strategies for an embodied cognitive neuroscience by Davy Mougenot and Heath Matheson
- Pick 1-2 of the 3 short articles below depending on your interest/time constraints:
- Meeting 4 (Aug. 21st): The Best Players, The Best Game
- Perception-language interface
- π A phone in a basket looks like a knife in a cup: Role-filler independence in visual processing by Alon Hafri et al.
- π Encoding of event roles from visual scenes is rapid, spontaneous, and interacts with higher-level visual processing by Alon Hafri et al.
- Optional for broader context:π The perception of relations by Alon Hafri & Chaz Firestone
- btw Alon should be guest-starring for this session!
- Meeting 5: Multiple Meanings
- Polysemy, a quick overview
- Meeting 6: Multiple Meanings
- Polysemy, cross-linguistic findings
- Meeting 7: Multiple Meanings
- Polysemy, developmental findings
- π Judging a book by its cover and its contents: The representation of polysemous and homophonous meanings in four-year-old children by Mahesh Srinivasan & Jesse Snedeker
- π Children use polysemy to structure new word meanings by Mahesh Srinivasan et al.
- π Learning novel phonological neighbors: Syntactic category matters by Isabelle Dautriche et al.
- This is about homophony rather than polysemy, but I feel it's interesting to read alongside the other experiments here.
- Meeting 8: Multiple Meanings
- Polysemy, recent blatherings
- Meeting 9: Multiple Meanings
- Polysemy, begin Conjoining Meanings
- π Conjoining Meanings: Semantics without truth values by Paul Pietroski
Additional resources
- Future topics of potential interest (based on survey)
- ACT-R
- Sign language intersections (editor's note: hell yeah)
- Session(s) where we share favorite/touchstone papers
- Dynamic semantics (e.g., Discourse Representation Theory, Dynamic Predicate Logic)
- Indian theories of meaning
- Conception metaphor theories
- 4E, embodiment
- Modularity of Mind
- Different kinds of memory
- Propositional vs. Depictive theories of Mental Representation
- old stuff!
- Potential Future Reads
- π The Language of Thought by Jerry Fodor
- π Language, Form, and Logic: In Pursuit of Natural Logic's Holy Grail by Peter Ludlow & SaΕ‘o Ε½ivanoviΔ
- π Computational Cognitive Modeling and Linguistic Theory by Adrian Brasoveanu & Jakub DotlaΔil
- Cool archival links
- π Form & Function in Language Evolution by Matt Spike
- πποΈ Smolensky vs. Fodor and Pylyshyn by Joe Pater
- π₯ The Language Science Series: Part 1 - Colorless Green Ideas by Gene Searchinger
- π₯ Is the Man Who Is Tall Happy? by Michel Gondry
- π₯ Connectionism & Cognitive Architecture by Jerry Fodor
- π Revolutionary Ideas Appear Infrequently by Michael Schiffmann
- Poems
- π΅ Natural linguistics by W.H. Auden
- π΅ Is wisdom a LoT of language? by Carl Sandburg